Communicating probabilities through interactive computer graphics

通过交互式计算机图形传达概率

• 批准号: 7134819
• 负责人: Rita Kukafka
• 金额: $ 5万
• 依托单位: COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY HEALTH SCIENCES
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 财政年份: 2006
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2006-07-01 至 2008-06-30
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://reporter.nih.gov/project-details/7134819
• 关键词: clinical research; disease /disorder proneness /risk; health education; human subject; interactive multimedia; mathematics

DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): The ability to understand quantitative information about probabilities is a critical component of health literacy. Although the probability of an event is only part of the multidimensional construct of perceived risk, probabilities are often used by experts and medical providers to convey risks to the public. Unfortunately, many people cannot understand or manipulate probabilities when they are presented as numbers. People of all educational levels are subject to cognitive biases when thinking about probabilities, and comprehension is further impaired by low educational level or numeracy. Among patients with low numeracy and educational level, comprehension is worst when probability information is presented in terms of probabilities or proportions, and best when it is presented through graphics that emphasize frequencies, such as grids of icons. However, not even graphical displays are successful with all audiences, and much previous research on them has been atheoretical. New research in cognitive psychology demonstrates that cognitive biases in probabilistic reasoning can be minimized or altered when probabilities are learned through experience (such as by drawing cards from a deck) rather than described as percentages (such as being told that 23 percent of the cards are face cards). Thus, we anticipate that we can improve comprehension and alter the effect on perceived risk by animating graphical displays to create virtual experiences of probabilities, and by encouraging users to interact with the displays and manipulate them. This study will (a) use qualitative methods with lay users to develop new computer-based graphical displays that incorporate animation and user interaction, (b) assess the effect of these displays in quantitative research on a large heterogeneous sample of users, and (c) explore the effects of numeracy and health literacy on comprehension of different display formats. The primary outcomes will be choice decisions between different risk scenarios, perceived risk, and quantitative comprehension. User satisfaction and interface usability will also be assessed. To enroll a diverse sample, we will recruit in both an on-line environment and from the Harlem Health Promotion Center, a national center for health promotion research. The interactive displays developed in this project have the potential to be applied to more comprehensive programs for health literacy education, tailored health and risk communication, shared medical decision-making, and patient decision support.

描述（由申请人提供）：理解概率定量信息的能力是健康素养的重要组成部分。 尽管事件的概率只是感知风险的多维结构的一部分，但专家和医疗提供者经常使用概率向公众传达风险。不幸的是，当概率以数字形式呈现时，许多人无法理解或操纵概率。所有教育水平的人在思考概率时都会受到认知偏差的影响，而较低的教育水平或算术能力会进一步损害理解力。对于计算能力和教育水平较低的患者来说，当概率信息以概率或比例的形式呈现时，理解力最差，而当通过强调频率的图形（例如图标网格）呈现时，理解力最好。然而，即使图形显示也并非对所有受众都成功，而且之前对它们的许多研究都是非理论的。认知心理学的新研究表明，当概率是通过经验（例如通过从一副牌中抽牌）而不是描述为百分比（例如被告知 23％ 的牌是面卡）。因此，我们预计我们可以通过动画图形显示来创建概率的虚拟体验，并鼓励用户与显示交互并操纵它们，从而提高理解力并改变对感知风险的影响。这项研究将（a）与非专业用户一起使用定性方法来开发新的基于计算机的图形显示，其中包含动画和用户交互，（b）评估这些显示在对大量异构用户样本的定量研究中的效果，以及（c） ）探索计算能力和健康素养对不同显示格式的理解的影响。主要结果将是不同风险情景、感知风险和定量理解之间的选择决策。还将评估用户满意度和界面可用性。为了招募多样化的样本，我们将通过在线环境和哈莱姆健康促进中心（国家健康促进研究中心）进行招募。该项目开发的交互式显示器有潜力应用于更全面的健康素养教育、定制健康和风险沟通、共享医疗决策和患者决策支持等项目。