Doctoral Dissertation Research: Expanding the Boundaries of Conservation Science: Community Based Wildlife Protection in the Maasai Ecosystem, Tanzania

博士论文研究：扩大保护科学的边界：坦桑尼亚马赛生态系统中基于社区的野生动物保护

• 批准号: 0201934
• 负责人: Matthew Turner
• 金额: $ 1.02万
• 依托单位: University of Wisconsin-Madison
• 依托单位国家: 美国
• 项目类别: Standard Grant
• 财政年份: 2002
• 资助国家: 美国
• 起止时间: 2002-03-01 至 2003-08-31
• 项目状态: 已结题
• 来源: https://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=0201934&HistoricalAwards=false
• 关键词: Doctoral; Dissertation; Research; Expanding; Boundaries

Community-based-conservation (CBC) projects are being initiated to protect wildlife corridors and connect ecological processes across landscapes. The conservation of wildlife in the Maasai Ecosystem of northern Tanzania relies on this approach for protection of migratory species outside of national parks on lands predominately occupied by Maasai pastoralists. The objective of this research project is to explore how the geographical knowledge of local Maasai residents contributes to scientific dialogues regarding CBC initiatives in the region that are based in both conservation biology and GIS (Geographic Information System) mapping. The project, therefore, involves a critical engagement with both local Maasai geographical knowledge and Western conservation science, to propose alternative wildlife conservation measures for the Maasai Ecosystem. The project explores theoretical questions regarding the value and place of indigenous knowledge within science and the politics of resource management, within the context of a political ecology research approach. The project first will ask what a Maasai geography of the region looks like, by exploring Maasai knowledge claims concerning historical as well as contemporary patterns of local ecology, wildlife resource use patterns, Maasai resource use patterns, Maasai-wildlife interactions, and Maasai notions of territoriality. The project will then investigate how dialogues of negotiation and translation can be built between Maasai knowledge and Conservation science by creating a final "text" of negotiation, based on in-depth ethnographic field work, ecological analysis, and participatory GIS mapping. Natural and social science techniques will include integrated use of in-depth interviews, key-informant led transects, group meetings, participant observations, ecological transects, air photo interpretation. In this manner, information obtained through social science methods will be continually reinforced and cross-checked, both geographically and with ecological methods. "Traveling" interviews with Maasai key informants will provide the most essential and innovative method used. By traveling with Maasai during their daily and seasonal land-use activities, ethno-botanical ecological sampling will be coupled with participatory observation and in-depth interviews to gain an understanding of Maasai resource use patterns and knowledge of local ecology. Ecological fieldwork will be conducted at specific sites deemed valuable for wildlife conservation purposes (as proposed by both conservation agencies and local Maasai) to delineate wildlife presence, wildlife-livestock interactions, and vegetation coverage at these sites. Participatory GIS mapping will be utilized to map information obtained through these combined methods. The challenges of translation and the politics of negotiating between competing knowledge claims, an essential component of the project, will be directly addressed throughout the project through self-reflective ethnography, participant observations, and additional interview questions. By investigating the process of incorporating/integrating local knowledge claims into conservation planning and GIS mapping, this project will directly address the social and ecological complexities involved in building new 'participatory' conservation geographies in human landscapes. By utilizing participatory GIS, the project will contribute to a better understanding of the capabilities of GIS as a technique for the translation and negotiation between different knowledge claims. The urgency with which CBC and participatory GIS mapping projects are being pursued throughout the developing world makes this research question a timely one for policy makers and academics alike. The project informs the theoretical frameworks of political ecology, science studies, GIS and critical cartographic theory, and conservation biology. Studies of local knowledge are often separated from critical reviews of science, and critical science studies is often theoretically removed from scientific productions. By combining the insights of science studies with a politically sensitive investigation of local knowledge and an ecological analysis of local land use, this study will transcend such disciplinary boundaries and open new doors for investigation into human-environment relations. As such, this project will contribute to a better understanding of the various ways in which we mediate the middle ground between conservation and development, people and nature, Western Scientific and local knowledge claims. As a Doctoral Dissertation Research Improvement award, this award also will provide support to enable a promising student to establish a strong independent research career.

基于社区的保护 (CBC) 项目正在启动，以保护野生动物走廊并连接各个景观的生态过程。 坦桑尼亚北部马赛生态系统的野生动物保护依靠这种方法来保护国家公园外主要由马赛牧民占据的土地上的迁徙物种。该研究项目的目的是探索当地马赛居民的地理知识如何有助于有关该地区基于保护生物学和 GIS（地理信息系统）制图的 CBC 举措的科学对话。 因此，该项目涉及当地马赛地理知识和西方保护科学的重要参与，为马赛生态系统提出替代野生动物保护措施。该项目在政治生态学研究方法的背景下，探讨了有关科学和资源管理政治中本土知识的价值和地位的理论问题。 该项目首先将通过探索马赛人关于历史和当代当地生态模式、野生动物资源利用模式、马赛人资源利用模式、马赛人与野生动物相互作用以及马赛人的概念的知识主张，询问该地区的马赛地理是什么样子。领土性。然后，该项目将研究如何在深入的民族志实地工作、生态分析和参与式 GIS 制图的基础上创建最终的谈判“文本”，从而在马赛知识和保护科学之间建立谈判和翻译的对话。自然和社会科学技术将包括综合使用深度访谈、关键信息主导的断面、小组会议、参与者观察、生态断面、航空照片解读。 通过这种方式，通过社会科学方法获得的信息将在地理和生态方法上不断得到加强和交叉检验。 对马赛关键知情人的“旅行”采访将提供所使用的最本质和创新的方法。 通过在马赛人的日常和季节性土地利用活动中与他们一起旅行，民族植物生态采样将与参与式观察和深入访谈相结合，以了解马赛人的资源利用模式和当地生态知识。 将在被认为对野生动物保护有价值的特定地点（根据保护机构和当地马赛人的提议）进行生态实地考察，以描绘这些地点的野生动物存在、野生动物与牲畜的相互作用以及植被覆盖范围。 将利用参与式 GIS 制图来绘制通过这些组合方法获得的信息。 翻译的挑战和相互竞争的知识主张之间谈判的政治是该项目的重要组成部分，将通过自我反思的民族志、参与者观察和其他访谈问题在整个项目中直接解决。 通过研究将当地知识主张纳入保护规划和地理信息系统制图的过程，该项目将直接解决在人文景观中建立新的“参与式”保护地理所涉及的社会和生态复杂性。通过利用参与式 GIS，该项目将有助于更好地理解 GIS 作为不同知识主张之间转换和协商技术的能力。 CBC 和参与式 GIS 制图项目在整个发展中国家的推行十分紧迫，这使得这一研究问题对于政策制定者和学者来说是一个及时的问题。该项目为政治生态学、科学研究、地理信息系统和批判制图理论以及保护生物学的理论框架提供了信息。 对当地知识的研究往往与对科学的批判性评论分开，而批判性科学研究往往在理论上与科学成果无关。 通过将科学研究的见解与对当地知识的政治敏感调查和对当地土地利用的生态分析相结合，这项研究将超越这些学科界限，为人类与环境关系的调查打开新的大门。 因此，该项目将有助于更好地理解我们在保护与发展、人与自然、西方科学和当地知识主张之间调解中间立场的各种方式。 作为博士论文研究改进奖，该奖项还将为有前途的学生建立强大的独立研究生涯提供支持。